When we think of groundbreaking technologies, our minds typically gravitate toward high-tech gadgets and futuristic concepts. However, the most game-changing innovations can be found in everyday activities, such as digging and excavation.
In an era where construction practices prioritize safety, efficiency, and environmental responsibility, the search for innovative solutions has led us to groundbreaking methods like vacuum excavation.
Vacuum excavation technology has quickly established itself in the construction sector, utility services, and other industries that demand safe and precise excavation.
In this article, we will explore how vacuum excavation is shaping the future of digging and why it’s gaining widespread adoption across the globe.
The downfall of traditional excavation
Before getting into vacuum excavation, let’s take a moment to understand the difficulties associated with traditional excavation.
In the past, people used to labor under the scorching midday sun, wielding shovels to excavate the earth and access intricate utilities. While these methods are effective to some extent, they have several drawbacks. Some of them are listed below.
- These methods could be slow and inefficient, resulting in increased project timelines and costs.
- During the excavation process, this method may often cause damage to the underground utilities, including water, gas, and electrical lines.
- This method can lead to the accumulation of soil debris adjacent to the excavation site, which may have repercussions on the overall visual appeal of the area.
The rise of vacuum excavation
In recent years, vacuum excavation has emerged as the solution to many of the problems associated with conventional digging.
This technology uses the kinetic energy from a stream of high-pressure air or water to break up the soil and then remove it through a powerful suction hose into a debris tank.
Based upon the agent used to break the soil, there are two types, namely
- Air vacuum excavation
- Hydro vacuum excavation
Each method has its own merits and demerits. Let’s explore each of them in detail.
1) Air vacuum excavation
This method uses compressed air as an agent to break up the cohesion between the soil so that it can be vacuumed through a suction pipe. Air vacuum excavation is also known as Airvac, pneumatic excavation, or air knife excavation.
Let’s discuss some of the pros and cons of using air vacuum excavation.
Pros of air vacuum excavation
1) Generally, Air is an infinite source. All you need is a compressor to generate a limitless supply of air at the site. Hence, airvac can be used at the sites where the availability of water is restricted.
2) The vacuumed soil from the airvac can be easily used as a backfill. When backfilling is not possible, it can be easily disposed of since the soil is not wet and heavy.
3) Air vacuum excavation generally operates under low pressure and force. Hence, air vacuum excavation generally does not affect the fragile utilities under the soil.
4) Generally, the equipment used for air vacuum excavation is smaller, lighter, and more economical.
Cons of air vacuum excavation
1) Because of the less force and power associated with the air vacuum excavation, it is not suitable for hard and dense ground.
2) Another by-product of less force is reduced speed. Air vacuum excavation may take a longer duration to complete the specific task. The harder the ground, the more effort and time will be required to perform the excavation process.
3) Air vacuum excavation may not be practical for jobs that require deeper excavation because the deeper you dig, the probability of soil becoming too hard and dense is high.
4) Sometimes in very dry conditions, the usage of air blast creates a dust cloud which may become detrimental for the excavation crew and surrounding areas.
2) Hydro vacuum excavation
This method uses a high-pressurized jet of water as an agent to break up the cohesion between the soil so that it can be vacuumed through a suction pipe and stored in the debris tank for disposal.
Hydro vacuum excavation is also known as hydrovac or hydro trenching.
Let’s discuss some of the pros and cons of using air vacuum excavation.
Pros of hydro vacuum excavation
1) The pressurized water from the nozzle penetrates and pulverizes nearly all types of soil. For projects that involve digging through hard, dense soils, hydro exaction is the best.
2) It increases the speed of excavation, making it extremely powerful and efficient.
3) It is often the most ideal option for large-scale projects, mostly because it has proven to be a faster and more economical method with greater precision.
4) Water is a natural lubricant, it can easily break the cohesion between the soil and is less harsh on utilities and excavation equipment.
5) It prevents the formation of dust clouds.
Cons of hydro vacuum excavation
1) Hydro vacuum excavation has a limited supply of water. It becomes a challenge when there is a significant distance between the work site and the nearest water source.
2) Hydrovac units require larger tanks of sufficient capacity. It must have two units, one is to store the clean water for jetting and the other one is for slurry which is vacuumed after excavation.
3) The soil excavated by the hydro-vac is wet and may not be suitable for the backfill.
Understanding the difference between these two methods is essential when determining the most suitable approach for a given task. The focus here is not on identifying the superior method but rather on opting for the one that ensures safety and cost-effectiveness for the specific job at hand.
Application of vacuum excavation
The versatility of vacuum excavation makes it suitable for various applications. Some of them are listed below.
1) Utility locating: Vacuum excavation is an invaluable tool for locating utilities that are buried under the soil with utmost precision, reducing the risk of damage during repair or installation work.
2) Potholing: It is used to create a small, precise hole for various works such as establishing fence posts, etc.
3) Trenching: It is used for creating small narrow trenches for laying cables and pipe networks.
4) Landscaping: It is widely used in landscaping for planting trees and shrubs.
5) Construction: It is used for various construction activities like foundation excavation, digging test pits, etc.
These are some of the few examples of how vacuum excavation is used for various tasks.
While the initial investment for vacuum excavation may be higher than traditional digging methods, the long-term benefits in terms of safety, efficiency, and cost savings are undeniable.
Hope you understand everything you need to know about vacuum excavation. If you found this article helpful, let us know in the comment section.
Read more:
A Comprehensive Guide to Different Types of Roof Flashing
